Logic Puzzle Answer

You’re looking at the answer to one of our logic puzzles. There are several other puzzles to figure out. Please click to find all our logic puzzles.

Never-Always Land - Answer

From Dick's first answer, we know he is lying. The Fishmongers always lie. Therefore, no one could honestly say that he is a Fishmonger. He must be a Wishy-Washie, who only lie alternately, making his second answer the truth.

Since Tom is telling the truth, he is therefore truly a Greenie.

From Harry's first answer, we can't tell if he is telling the truth or lying. But his second answer is a lie because we know Tom is a Greenie. Harry cannot be a Greenie because Greenies don't lie. Therefore, he must be a Fishmonger.